Let's say you're an Amazon engineer. Amazon item review scores are sometimes biased because people usually only give a rating if they strongly like it or strongly dislike it. How would you know if a rating for an item is biased or not?
Question Analysis
The question is asking you to identify potential biases in Amazon's item review scores. As an Amazon engineer, you are expected to understand the dynamics of customer reviews and ratings. The question suggests that customer ratings may not be entirely representative of the general customer sentiment because people with strong opinions (either positive or negative) are more likely to leave a review. Your task is to devise a method or approach to determine if a rating is biased. This involves understanding the data, identifying patterns of bias, and suggesting ways to measure or correct for this bias.
Answer
To determine if a rating for an item is biased, you can follow these steps:
-
Data Collection and Analysis:
- Collect a broad dataset of reviews and ratings for various products over time.
- Analyze the distribution of ratings to identify patterns. Look for a U-shaped distribution, which indicates that most reviews are either very positive or very negative, leaving out moderate opinions.
-
Identify Patterns and Indicators of Bias:
- Detect skewness: Calculate the skewness of the ratings distribution. A high skewness may indicate bias.
- Look for outliers: Identify any anomalies in the data, such as an unusually high number of 5-star or 1-star ratings.
- Review frequency: Check if certain items have significantly fewer reviews despite high sales, which may indicate a bias towards strong opinions.
-
Comparative Analysis:
- Benchmark against similar products: Compare the rating distribution of the item in question with similar products in the category. A significant deviation might suggest bias.
- Temporal analysis: Analyze how the ratings change over time. A sudden spike in ratings might indicate a temporary bias due to external factors.
-
Customer Feedback and Surveys:
- Conduct surveys: Reach out to a broader audience to get feedback, especially focusing on those who did not leave a review, to understand their perspective.
- Incentivize moderate reviews: Encourage reviews from customers with moderate opinions to balance the extremes.
-
Statistical Techniques:
- Use sentiment analysis: Apply sentiment analysis on the review texts to see if the sentiment matches the given rating.
- Apply machine learning models: Use models to predict expected ratings based on review text and compare them with actual ratings to detect discrepancies.
By systematically analyzing the data and employing comparative and statistical techniques, you can identify potential biases in item ratings and take steps to correct or account for them.